A Look Back at the Historical Roots of the S&W Model 19
The world of firearms is filled with legendary designs, guns that have earned their place in history through reliability, performance, and a certain undeniable appeal. Among these, the Smith & Wesson Model 19 stands out. Revered for its blend of power, accuracy, and manageability, the Model 19 has been a favorite among law enforcement officers, sport shooters, and concealed carry enthusiasts for decades. But the firearms world is constantly evolving, and Smith & Wesson, never one to rest on its laurels, has reimagined this iconic revolver for the modern era: the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp. This article dives deep into the features, performance, and appeal of this modern take on a classic, exploring what makes it a compelling option for those seeking a powerful and concealable handgun.
To truly appreciate the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp, it’s crucial to understand the legacy it’s built upon. The original Model 19 was a collaborative effort, born out of a partnership between Smith & Wesson and the legendary firearms expert, Colonel Rex Applegate. Applegate, a champion of the .357 Magnum cartridge for its stopping power, wanted a revolver that could handle the potent round while remaining controllable and relatively easy to carry.
The design utilized Smith & Wesson’s K-frame, a size offering a good balance between compactness and strength. Chambered in the formidable .357 Magnum, the Model 19 could also fire the less powerful .38 Special rounds, providing versatility for different shooting needs and levels of experience. A hallmark of the original Model 19 was its exceptional accuracy, often achieved through the use of target-style adjustable sights. These sights, along with the gun’s ergonomic design, made it a natural fit for both target shooting and self-defense scenarios.
The Model 19 quickly became a favorite of law enforcement agencies across the United States. Its combination of power, accuracy, and manageable size made it ideal for patrol officers and plainclothes detectives. Civilian shooters also embraced the Model 19, recognizing its versatility for everything from home defense to recreational shooting. Its reputation for reliability and robust construction, coupled with its ability to handle the potent .357 Magnum round, solidified its place as a true classic. The enduring popularity of the original S&W Model 19 speaks volumes about the quality of the design.
Key Features of the Modern Carry Comp
The S&W Model 19 Carry Comp retains the spirit of the original while incorporating modern enhancements designed to improve performance and make it even more suitable for concealed carry. Let’s examine some of its key features.
The K-frame, a cornerstone of the original design, remains the foundation of the Carry Comp. This frame offers a balance between manageable size and comfortable handling, making it easier to conceal than larger revolvers while still providing a solid platform for firing powerful .357 Magnum rounds. The overall dimensions, while not as small as some pocket pistols, are still well within the realm of comfortable concealed carry, especially when considering the added benefits the Carry Comp offers.
The most striking feature of the Carry Comp is undoubtedly its ported barrel and compensator. This is the defining characteristic that separates it from the original. The barrel is strategically ported near the muzzle, and the compensator helps redirect propellant gases upwards, reducing felt recoil and muzzle climb. This reduction in recoil allows for faster and more accurate follow-up shots, a crucial advantage in self-defense situations. The design effectively tames the recoil impulse of the .357 Magnum, making it feel more like shooting a .38 Special, yet with all the power of the magnum round.
The grips on the Carry Comp are another area of significant change. Smith & Wesson typically outfits the Carry Comp with grips designed to offer a secure and comfortable hold. These grips often feature a textured surface to enhance grip and control, even when hands are wet or sweaty. The grips also provide a better purchase on the firearm and help distribute the recoil force more evenly, further contributing to the overall comfort and shootability. The grip design plays a vital role in both comfort and control.
The sights on the Carry Comp are generally upgraded compared to the original Model 19. Modern designs may incorporate a fiber optic front sight for rapid target acquisition, alongside an adjustable rear sight or a fixed rear sight with a broader notch. These improved sights offer a clearer sight picture and contribute to faster and more accurate target engagement, vital for defensive scenarios. The sights are often designed for quick and intuitive aiming, making it easier to get on target.
Beyond these key features, the Carry Comp often incorporates other refinements, depending on the specific variant. The trigger is often tuned to provide a smooth and consistent pull in both single-action and double-action modes. The finish may be a modern corrosion-resistant material, offering enhanced durability and protection against the elements. The attention to detail throughout the design is a testament to Smith & Wesson’s commitment to quality.
Analyzing the Performance and Handling Experience
The true test of any firearm lies in its performance. The S&W Model 19 Carry Comp excels in several areas, making it a joy to shoot and a capable tool for self-defense.
The effectiveness of the compensator is immediately noticeable. The reduced recoil is the primary advantage of this design. The upward expulsion of gases significantly mitigates muzzle climb, allowing the shooter to maintain a more consistent sight picture and get back on target quickly. This translates into faster and more accurate follow-up shots. It is especially beneficial when shooting the full-power .357 Magnum ammunition. The compensator truly transforms the shooting experience.
Accuracy is a hallmark of the Model 19, and the Carry Comp maintains this tradition. With its enhanced sights and overall design, the Carry Comp is capable of impressive accuracy at various distances. The well-defined sights combined with the reduced recoil allow for tight groupings and precise shot placement, making it an effective tool for both self-defense and target shooting.
The trigger pull on the Carry Comp is a key element of the shooting experience. The improved triggers offer a smooth and consistent pull, allowing for greater control and precision. The trigger pull is crisp and predictable, contributing to the overall accuracy and enjoyment of shooting the revolver.
Ergonomics play a crucial role in handling. The Carry Comp is designed to fit comfortably in the hand, allowing for a secure and natural grip. The grip design is excellent, providing a solid platform for managing recoil and maintaining control. The thoughtful design of the grips makes it easy to get a good purchase on the gun, enhancing both comfort and control.
Reliability is paramount in a self-defense firearm, and the Carry Comp is known for its robust and reliable performance. The Smith & Wesson K-frame platform is known for its durability, and the Carry Comp is built to withstand the rigors of regular use. This gives shooters confidence that their firearm will perform when it is most needed.
Advantages that the Carry Comp Brings to the Table
The S&W Model 19 Carry Comp offers several advantages that make it a compelling choice for concealed carry and personal defense.
Improved recoil control is the standout benefit. The compensator effectively tames the .357 Magnum cartridge, allowing for faster and more accurate follow-up shots. This is a significant advantage in a self-defense situation where every split second counts.
Faster target acquisition is another key benefit. The improved sights and reduced muzzle climb allow shooters to quickly acquire and engage targets. This is particularly crucial in high-stress scenarios.
Concealability is enhanced, despite the addition of the compensator. The compact dimensions, especially combined with the comfortable grips, allow for relatively easy concealment under a variety of clothing. The reduced recoil and manageable size makes concealed carry with this model much more feasible than with the original.
The modern enhancements, such as the updated sights, trigger, and finish, all contribute to a better shooting experience and improved performance compared to the original Model 19. These modern touches elevate the overall quality and desirability of the Carry Comp.
Considering the Potential Downsides and Considerations
While the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp offers many advantages, there are also a few potential drawbacks and considerations to keep in mind.
The muzzle blast and flash from the compensator can be more pronounced than on a standard revolver. This is a side effect of the way the compensator redirects gases. This increased blast and flash could potentially be a disadvantage in low-light situations.
Size and weight, although manageable for concealed carry, might be a consideration for some. The K-frame isn’t as compact as some smaller carry options. This may be a factor for some shooters, particularly those who prefer smaller, lighter handguns.
The potential for carbon buildup in the compensator is another factor to consider. Regular cleaning is necessary to maintain its effectiveness and prevent it from malfunctioning. This is a minor consideration, but regular maintenance is important for optimum performance.
The price of the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp is typically higher than the original Model 19, reflecting the added features and modern enhancements. This premium price may be a barrier for some buyers.
Comparing the Carry Comp to its Classic Counterpart
While the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp builds upon the legacy of the original Model 19, there are significant differences between the two.
The original Model 19, while legendary, lacks the compensator and some of the modern enhancements found in the Carry Comp. The K-frame, however, remains a constant. The ability to fire .357 Magnum rounds, along with .38 Special, is a core component.
The most significant difference is the presence of the compensator, which reduces recoil and muzzle climb. The Carry Comp often includes improved sights and modern finishes.
The advantages of the Carry Comp include its superior recoil control, faster target acquisition, and modern enhancements. The original Model 19 has a less complex design and may have a lower price.
Shooters who want a classic, reliable revolver, without the added complexity of a compensator, may prefer the original Model 19. Shooters who prioritize faster follow-up shots, enhanced recoil control, and appreciate modern enhancements, will prefer the S&W Model 19 Carry Comp.
Concluding Thoughts: A Timeless Design, Modernized
The S&W Model 19 Carry Comp represents a thoughtful and effective modernization of a true classic. It takes the best elements of the original Model 19 – its reliable K-frame, powerful .357 Magnum chambering, and overall aesthetic – and adds modern enhancements to improve performance and make it even more suitable for concealed carry.
The reduced recoil, enhanced sights, and comfortable grips make the Carry Comp a pleasure to shoot, offering excellent control and accuracy. While it has a few minor drawbacks, the advantages, especially for those seeking a powerful and concealable handgun, are undeniable.
The Model 19, in all its iterations, remains a testament to the enduring appeal of well-designed firearms. The S&W Model 19 Carry Comp ensures that this legacy continues, providing shooters with a modern take on a classic that is both powerful and practical. Whether for self-defense, range use, or simply appreciating a fine piece of engineering, the Carry Comp is a compelling option that deserves consideration.
